AIPNews.com  |  About AIP  |  Platform  |  Personal Affiliation  |  Contribute Search  |  Inbox  |  My Settings  |  Log-in  

America's Independent Party

Securing the Blessings of Liberty

Featured Forum:

America's Forum at AIPNews - 'We are the Media!'

All posts by date

(Must affiliate to post)


What the Pelosi Health-Care Bill Really Says
::
   AIP Projects and Special Committees -> Obama Watch - 'Say NO to Socialism!'

Wall Street Journal 

November 6, 2009

Betsy McCaughey

The health bill that House Speaker Nancy Pelosi is bringing to a vote (H.R. 3962) is 1,990 pages. Here are some of the details you need to know.

What the government will require you to do:

• Sec. 202 (p. 91-92) of the bill requires you to enroll in a "qualified plan." If you get your insurance at work, your employer will have a "grace period" to switch you to a "qualified plan," meaning a plan designed by the Secretary of Health and Human Services. If you buy your own insurance, there's no grace period. You'll have to enroll in a qualified plan as soon as any term in your contract changes, such as the co-pay, deductible or benefit.

• Sec. 224 (p. 118) provides that 18 months after the bill becomes law, the Secretary of Health and Human Services will decide what a "qualified plan" covers and how much you'll be legally required to pay for it. That's like a banker telling you to sign the loan agreement now, then filling in the interest rate and repayment terms 18 months later.

On Nov. 2, the Congressional Budget Office estimated what the plans will likely cost. An individual earning $44,000 before taxes who purchases his own insurance will have to pay a $5,300 premium and an estimated $2,000 in out-of-pocket expenses, for a total of $7,300 a year, which is 17% of his pre-tax income. A family earning $102,100 a year before taxes will have to pay a $15,000 premium plus an estimated $5,300 out-of-pocket, for a $20,300 total, or 20% of its pre-tax income. Individuals and families earning less than these amounts will be eligible for subsidies paid directly to their insurer.

• Sec. 303 (pp. 167-168) makes it clear that, although the "qualified plan" is not yet designed, it will be of the "one size fits all" variety. The bill claims to offer choice—basic, enhanced and premium levels—but the benefits are the same. Only the co-pays and deductibles differ. You will have to enroll in the same plan, whether the government is paying for it or you and your employer are footing the bill.

• Sec. 59b (pp. 297-299) says that when you file your taxes, you must include proof that you are in a qualified plan. If not, you will be fined thousands of dollars. Illegal immigrants are exempt from this requirement.

• Sec. 412 (p. 272) says that employers must provide a "qualified plan" for their employees and pay 72.5% of the cost, and a smaller share of family coverage, or incur an 8% payroll tax. Small businesses, with payrolls from $500,000 to $750,000, are fined less.

Eviscerating Medicare:

In addition to reducing future Medicare funding by an estimated $500 billion, the bill fundamentally changes how Medicare pays doctors and hospitals, permitting the government to dictate treatment decisions.

• Sec. 1302 (pp. 672-692) moves Medicare from a fee-for-service payment system, in which patients choose which doctors to see and doctors are paid for each service they provide, toward what's called a "medical home."

The medical home is this decade's version of HMO-restrictions on care. A primary-care provider manages access to costly specialists and diagnostic tests for a flat monthly fee. The bill specifies that patients may have to settle for a nurse practitioner rather than a physician as the primary-care provider. Medical homes begin with demonstration projects, but the HHS secretary is authorized to "disseminate this approach rapidly on a national basis."

A December 2008 Congressional Budget Office report noted that "medical homes" were likely to resemble the unpopular gatekeepers of 20 years ago if cost control was a priority.

• Sec. 1114 (pp. 391-393) replaces physicians with physician assistants in overseeing care for hospice patients.

• Secs. 1158-1160 (pp. 499-520) initiates programs to reduce payments for patient care to what it costs in the lowest cost regions of the country. This will reduce payments for care (and by implication the standard of care) for hospital patients in higher cost areas such as New York and Florida.

• Sec. 1161 (pp. 520-545) cuts payments to Medicare Advantage plans (used by 20% of seniors). Advantage plans have warned this will result in reductions in optional benefits such as vision and dental care.

• Sec. 1402 (p. 756) says that the results of comparative effectiveness research conducted by the government will be delivered to doctors electronically to guide their use of "medical items and services."

Questionable Priorities:

While the bill will slash Medicare funding, it will also direct billions of dollars to numerous inner-city social work and diversity programs with vague standards of accountability.

• Sec. 399V (p. 1422) provides for grants to community "entities" with no required qualifications except having "documented community activity and experience with community healthcare workers" to "educate, guide, and provide experiential learning opportunities" aimed at drug abuse, poor nutrition, smoking and obesity. "Each community health worker program receiving funds under the grant will provide services in the cultural context most appropriate for the individual served by the program."

These programs will "enhance the capacity of individuals to utilize health services and health related social services under Federal, State and local programs by assisting individuals in establishing eligibility . . . and in receiving services and other benefits" including transportation and translation services.

• Sec. 222 (p. 617) provides reimbursement for culturally and linguistically appropriate services. This program will train health-care workers to inform Medicare beneficiaries of their "right" to have an interpreter at all times and with no co-pays for language services.

• Secs. 2521 and 2533 (pp. 1379 and 1437) establishes racial and ethnic preferences in awarding grants for training nurses and creating secondary-school health science programs. For example, grants for nursing schools should "give preference to programs that provide for improving the diversity of new nurse graduates to reflect changes in the demographics of the patient population." And secondary-school grants should go to schools "graduating students from disadvantaged backgrounds including racial and ethnic minorities."

• Sec. 305 (p. 189) Provides for automatic Medicaid enrollment of newborns who do not otherwise have insurance.

For the text of the bill with page numbers, see www.defendyourhealthcare.us.

Ms. McCaughey is chairman of the Committee to Reduce Infection Deaths and a former Lt. Governor of New York state.

  •  


Read more at online.wsj.com ...

Posted 2009-11-06 6:33 PM (#27548) By: EternalVigilance

Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

Latest Posts From All Affiliates
Around the Web News Views at AIPNews.com ... Friday, November 20, 2009 - Savvy (4 replies)

Silence, the defense of slavery - gcsteven (23 replies)

Marco Rubio - Savvy (31 replies)

Catholic/Evangelical/Orthodox leaders to release manifesto in Washington today [Romney connection?] - Gregory (9 replies)

Let Rev. Manning be heard! - ALAN KEYES - Philomena (1 replies)

STATE-by-STATE Rally Against Healthcare Reform, Saturday, November 21, 2009 - Savvy (20 replies)

STREET PREACHER ARRESTED AT GAY BAR - Case Dismissed! - nmaureen (0 replies)

Health Care Cost Nightmare - EternalVigilance (0 replies)

Obama: Israel on dangerous path [response from the God of Israel pending] - EternalVigilance (0 replies)

Radical Homosexual Lobby gearing up to pass ENDA - EternalVigilance (0 replies)

Obama Watch at AIPNews.com 11/20/09 - helenm (0 replies)

Politico's commentary on the state of the Tea Party movement - EternalVigilance (0 replies)

Tea Party Rallies in Minot [North Dakota] - EternalVigilance (1 replies)

Audio recording available - AIP's November 19, 2009 America's Summit: Restore The Republic call - SteveSchulin (1 replies)

EVERYONE IS TALKING, WHO IS THIS JIM ANDERSON? [Dr. Keyes visits KS!] - Editor (0 replies)

Glorious Things Are Said Of Him - DAVID JEFFERS - Editor (0 replies)

Founders' Quotes - Editor (90 replies)

Pelosi Won't Say If Bin Laden Has 'Right To Remain Silent' [as the travesty in NY continues] - Editor (4 replies)

Senate confirms controversial judge to federal bench - Editor (0 replies)

Energy-saving bulbs 'get dimmer' - Editor (0 replies)

Married couples face extra tax in Senate health care bill - Editor (0 replies)

Energy independence most important priority - Editor (0 replies)

Belgian PM is first 'president of Europe' - Editor (0 replies)

All that health care reform money - for nothing - EternalVigilance (0 replies)

DAILY PRAYER by Chaplain "Chaps" Gordon James Klingenschmitt - Savvy (35 replies)

A Brief Legislative History of Social Security - larrymwalkerjr (0 replies)

Open Letter: PLEASE JOIN A.I.P. - rapndiamond (2 replies)

Obama Tells Troops: "You guys make a pretty good photo op" - Philomena (6 replies)

Texas - Definition of an Individual - rapndiamond (6 replies)

LifeSiteNews Headlines November 19, 2009 - Philomena (0 replies)

Obama may put Americans under world judges' power - marchingon (0 replies)

I WOULD LIKE TO ISSUE A COMPLAINT - Savvy (5 replies)

America's Summit - Restore the Republic - Every Tues., Thurs., & Sat. - 9 pm Eastern [call info] - Philomena (7 replies)

Frederick County Maryland Under Attack - SteveSchulin (4 replies)

Rev. Manning has had a visit from the Secret Service - Philomena (10 replies)

GOP senator backs off threat to read health bill [Coburn wimps out] - EternalVigilance (0 replies)

California Chaos - EternalVigilance (0 replies)

When Reality Catches up to Rhetoric - EternalVigilance (0 replies)

It is Home Which Decides the Nation - gcsteven (0 replies)

Faith and Action Stages First Live Christmas Nativity Scene in Front of the Supreme Court - nmaureen (0 replies)

Giuliani admits that Bush was soft on Muslims - TomKovach-AIP-TN (0 replies)

VIRUS in the VOTING MACHINES: Tainted Results in NY-23 - Scott_Thomas (2 replies)

Personhood and Personalism Imperative - Philomena (12 replies)

Dr. Manning directly addresses Youtube issues ["Im sick of it! This is worse than Communist China!"] - MaryAnnH (1 replies)

Schools let students seek secret abortions [CA] - EternalVigilance (1 replies)

Till the Revolution Comes [Hon. James David Manning calls Obama "the alleged President"] - EternalVigilance (17 replies)

The first President of Europe - danielh41 (0 replies)

Rev. Manning's Statements & Testament - EternalVigilance (2 replies)

Exclusive: Vulture Political Cartoon by AIP Affiliate Nate Connell - Philomena (10 replies)

Visiting Maj. Nidal Hasan's Hospital - by Chuck Norris - Massachusetts (0 replies)

Personhood and the Ontology of Personalism: - gcsteven (19 replies)

Gary Glenn Responds to Regrettable Mormon Church Decision to Back 'Gay Rights' Laws - EternalVigilance (1 replies)

Hoffman alleges vote fraud in NY-23 - Philomena (2 replies)

CATHOLIC CAMPAIGN FOR HUMAN DEVELOPMENT SCANDAL CONTINUES - Philomena (5 replies)

The BIGGEST LIE Yet - EternalVigilance (0 replies)

NV Life Groups [incl. CP affiliates] in League with Planned Parenthood; Try to Stop Pro-Life Efforts - Gregory (5 replies)

9/11 mom confronts Holder: Why are you doing this? - Philomena (2 replies)

Dance of the death tax continues - 2010 'free ride' anomoly surely to be snuffed - SteveSchulin (0 replies)

Coulter: Congress and the WTC Terrorists - Scott_Thomas (0 replies)

Personhood Florida invites you this Saturday! - EternalVigilance (0 replies)

Why Typical Americans Hate Unions, Part XXXVIII - SonofAsaph (1 replies)

Maryland - Baltimore Mayor trial ends up being about $630 of gift cards - SteveSchulin (0 replies)

Islam: What the West Needs to Know - Philomena (1 replies)

Obama Watch at AIPNews.com 11/19/09 - helenm (0 replies)

NY23-Owens would keep seat, even if Hoffman is found to have won, if GOP-urged 2006 precedent stands - Roundhead (3 replies)

USCCB Approves Strongly-Worded Document Affirming Value of Natural Marriage - Philomena (0 replies)

Maersk Alabama crew repels another pirate attack - this time they had guns - TomKovach-AIP-TN (5 replies)